Skip to content

Completing your self-assessment – strong examples

Here are 2 fictional examples to show how a selection panel might grade the evidence in your self-assessment using the Judicial Skills and Abilities Framework.

Strong example 1 (Grade B)

Skill and ability – Dealing With Information

  • Assimilates and organises pertinent information quickly.
  • Identifies with clarity relevant issues of fact and law for decision.
  • Reaches clearly reasoned, logical and concise decisions that weigh up relevant considerations.
  • Demonstrates sound judgement and an appropriate level of decisiveness.

“I received a case for a prosecution decision, of a young autistic woman accused of assault. The police had also done welfare checks and on two occasions she had kicked an officer. I carefully considered the paperwork, including the complaints, medical notes, mental health reports and relevant guidance. I organised and weighed up information from thousands of pages, sorting it by key issue. Importantly, in one mental health report, I found a reference to kicking being one of her stims for self-calming. I made a decision using the gravity matrix (a triage tool to consider out-of-court disposal of a case), recommending to the police that a caution would be the appropriate action. The police response was abrupt and irritated; they said I was completely wrong and that there should be a prosecution. I carefully reviewed my initial decision to check for errors but found nothing wrong in my reasoning. Nonetheless, I took time to further explain my decision. Later I received a call from a senior officer asking me to reconsider; I refused as I was confident with my decision. The police then wrote to me, copying in my line management, stating that they would only agree with my view if forced to at court. We proceeded to several court hearings but ultimately the police withdrew the case. Afterwards I reviewed my actions and made some changes to the way I explain my decisions, to increase clarity.”

How the panel assess applications

Here are example notes of how a selection panel might assess the evidence above. They show what makes a strong application.

Sentences from the examplePanel analysis
“I received a case for a prosecution decision, of a young autistic woman accused of assault. The police had also done welfare checks and on two occasions she had kicked an officer.”This sets out the background to the example, clearly and succinctly. To achieve the highest grade, the candidate could have clarified who the accusations of assault came from – was it only the police or was there another complainant?
“I carefully considered the paperwork, including the complaints, medical notes, mental health reports and relevant guidance. I organised and weighed up information from thousands of pages, sorting it by key issue. Importantly, in one mental health report, I found a reference to kicking being one of her stims for self-calming.”This sets out clearly what the candidate did, in line with the first two bullet points of Dealing With Information. It explains the assimilation and organisation process and highlights the candidate finding a key piece of evidence. The candidate gives helpful specifics such as the volume of information analysed, though they did not say how long they spent on the analysis or specify exactly what they weighed up.
“I made a decision using the gravity matrix (a triage tool to consider out-of-court disposal of a case), recommending to the police that a caution would be the appropriate action.”This explains the candidate’s decision-making process, in line with the third bullet point of Dealing With Information. The candidate briefly explains what a gravity matrix is, which is helpful for lay panel members.
“The police response was abrupt and irritated; they said I was completely wrong and that there should be a prosecution. I carefully reviewed my initial decision to check for errors but found nothing wrong in my reasoning. Nonetheless, I took time to further explain my decision. Later I received a call from a senior officer asking me to reconsider; I refused as I was confident with my decision. The police then wrote to me, copying in my line management, stating that they would only agree with my view if forced to at court. We proceeded to several court hearings but ultimately the police withdrew the case.”This section covers the third and fourth bullet points of Dealing With Information, specifically decision-making and judgement. It explains the candidate’s actions clearly. It shows the candidate was decisive, since after review, they stood by their decision. It shows sound judgement as the police withdrew the case. It also shows that this situation was challenging and complex (which is important to get the higher grades of A and B), as the candidate’s decision was questioned and later escalated to their line management.
“Afterwards I reviewed my actions and made some changes to the way I explain my decisions, to increase clarity.”This shows that the candidate reflected on, and learned from, their actions. Whilst not strictly part of Dealing With Information, this indicates learning and improvement, so is a positive way to end an example.

In summary:

  • this example is clearly relevant to Dealing With Information
  • it clearly sets out what the candidate did and how they did it
  • the example shows challenge and complexity, which is needed to achieve a B (strong) or A (outstanding) grade
  • this example would likely be graded as B (strong evidence) by the panel
  • there were some omissions, highlighted in the comments above, which explain why it doesn’t meet the A (outstanding) level of evidence

Strong example 2 (Grade B)

Skill and ability – Legal Skills 

  • Possesses intellectual ability and analytical skills to the standard required for the role. 
  • Demonstrates legal skills and knowledge to the standard required for the role. 
  • Is able and willing to invest time in developing and maintaining skills and knowledge as appropriate for the role. 
  • Shows flexibility of approach: can apply skills and knowledge in unfamiliar or developing areas, as appropriate for the role. 
  • Clearly understands what is required for a fair hearing. 

“I acted for a claimant in a case relating to mis-selling of a bank product, which flowed from a loan he had taken out for his small business. This was a new area for me. It was prior to the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) intervention, so there was limited caselaw, and the legislation and regulations were complex. Undeterred, I started researching and familiarised myself with the different parts of the claim, the relevant regulations and other cases.  

“I drew on materials from the FCA and the Financial Ombudsman Service. I obtained the product sourcebook, and I explored whether, as a small business, my client would be classed as an individual or corporate entity. I located and booked onto financial services training for solicitors to rapidly build my knowledge and joined a relevant solicitors’ network to further assist me.  

“Armed with the knowledge from research and training, I analysed my client’s case carefully to check his evidence against breaches of the regulations. I saw that he had misunderstood some of the process and evidence required to bring a strong claim. In discussion, and then in writing, I provided advice on the evidence that would be required and on refocusing some parts of his case to better structure it against the regulations and more clearly demonstrate the breaches.  

“In the end, my client had an effective case and the bank decided to settle shortly after parties arrived at court. After conducting several more cases and being approached by a colleague, I later decided to run a training seminar on mis-selling cases, so that colleagues at my firm could benefit from my learning. It was well-attended and received positive feedback.” 

How the panel assess applications 

Here are example notes of how a selection panel might assess the evidence above. They show what makes a strong application. 

Sentences from the example Panel analysis 
“I acted for a claimant in a case relating to mis-selling of a bank product, which flowed from a commercial loan he had taken out for his small business. This was a new area for me. It was prior to the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) intervention so there was limited caselaw, and the legislation and regulations were complex.” This sets out the background to the example, clearly and succinctly. It explains why this situation was challenging/complex. 
“Undeterred, I started researching and familiarised myself with the different parts of the claim, the relevant regulations and other cases. I drew on materials from the FCA and the Financial Ombudsman Service. I obtained the product sourcebook, and I explored whether, as a small business, my client would be classed as an individual or corporate entity. I located and booked onto financial services training for solicitors to rapidly build my knowledge and joined a relevant solicitors’ network to further assist me.” This sets out clearly what the candidate did to build their knowledge, in line with the third bullet point of Legal Skills. It explains the research and training they undertook and includes some specifics such as the sources of information they used and one of the issues they explored.  As a minor point, it is not clear why the issue of how the client is classed makes a difference to the case. 
“Armed with the knowledge from research and training, I analysed my client’s case carefully to check his evidence against breaches of the regulations. I saw that he had misunderstood some of the process and evidence required to bring a strong claim. In discussion, and then in writing, I provided advice on the evidence that would be required and on refocusing some parts of his case to better structure it against the regulations and more clearly demonstrate the breaches.” This section demonstrates analysis of the issues, in line with the first bullet point of Legal Skills, demonstration of knowledge, in line with the second bullet point, and application of knowledge in an unfamiliar area, in line with the fourth bullet point.  To get the highest grade, the candidate could have added further detail of the advice given and the difference it made. For example, what the client changed/added/focused on thereafter. 
“In the end, my client had an effective case and the bank decided to settle shortly after parties arrived at court.” This summarises the result of the case and shows that the candidate achieved a positive outcome for the client. 
“After conducting several more cases and being approached by a colleague, I later decided to run a training seminar on mis-selling cases, so that colleagues at my firm could benefit from my learning. It was well-attended and received positive feedback.” This shows that the candidate continued to apply their knowledge after this event, and consolidated and shared it with other solicitors.  

In summary: 

  • this example is clearly relevant to Legal Skills and covers four of the five bullet points 
  • it clearly sets out what the candidate did and how they did it 
  • the example shows challenge and complexity, which is needed to achieve a B (strong) or A (outstanding) grade 
  • this example would likely be graded as B (strong evidence) by the panel
  • there were some minor parts that were unclear and some omissions, as highlighted in the comments above, which is why it doesn’t meet the A (outstanding) level of evidence

Note: The examples above are just to help you understand how a panel would find (or fail to find) evidence in what a candidate presents. Copying these examples and changing a few words to make them personal to you will not guarantee a high grade. It is much better to create your own examples from scratch, using these tips. 

More help with examples of an insufficient self-assessment